This is the list that I used for my 2nd set of mailings:
Crown Point, IN
51 To 60 %
61 To 70 %
71 To 80 %
81 To 90 %
91 To 100 %
Last Market Sale Date
Here’s the link to the blog if you want to see how many records I got back and how I set up the mailing:
This list has performed very poorly for me so far. I have done 2 weeks of mailing to total of 3,600 records or so have received back 10 calls with a lot of them asking me to take them off the mailing list. There hasn’t been any decent lead so far from this list.
So as of today, my call back rate is a whopping 0.28% (I am rounding it up very slightly to feel better about the call back rate).
The call back rate is disappointing for sure but I speak with investors from all over the country, some that are using our direct mail service and some that are using another company and it’s not uncommon to see call back rate this low for some competitive market and low motivation sellers.
Just the other day I had dinner with another investor who uses a competitor for direct mail and sends around 2,000 mailers/week in a competitive market and his response rate for last 3 months has been 0.25% for postcards.
Based on what I learn, you gotta have a good list and then continue mailing to that list over and over again. The mail design doesn’t make as much difference as the list you are mailing to and persistently sending to that list over and over again does.
I am going to continue sending to this list and see how the results vary by changing the mailer type.